top of page

Fantasy Books With an Executioner as the Main Character

2 days ago
5 min read

I've spent five books inside the head of an executioner, so I have opinions about this, and most of them are about how weirdly few of these books exist.

Think about it. Fantasy is wall to wall with swords, kings and people getting their heads cut off, and almost nobody wants to tell the story from the point of view of the bloke actually holding the axe. Which is a shame, because he's the perfect narrator. He works for the state and the state despises him. He sees every rotten law at the exact moment it's carried out. Everybody in town knows his face, or at least his hood, and nobody wants to sit next to him in the tavern.

So here's a list of fantasy books with an executioner (or the next closest thing, a torturer) as the main character, plus a couple of historical ones for when you want the real-world version, and one of mine at the end, because I'd be a fool not to.

The Shadow of the Torturer, by Gene Wolfe

The grandfather of the lot. Severian is an apprentice in the guild of torturers, a proper medieval craft guild with masters, apprentices and a tower full of clients, in a far-future world so old the sun is dying. He commits the one crime his guild can't forgive, which is mercy, and gets packed off to a distant city to work as an executioner, carrying a sword called Terminus Est.

It's the first of The Book of the New Sun, and it's dense, strange and a little bit slippery, because Severian is not a narrator you should fully trust. If you like a book you have to work at, and that rewards you for it for years afterwards, this is the one. It's also the best argument there is that an executioner's job can carry an entire epic.

The Blade Itself, by Joe Abercrombie

Not an executioner, but Sand dan Glokta is too good to leave off. He was a dashing cavalry officer once. Then he spent two years in the Emperor's prisons, came home crippled, and took a job with the Inquisition, asking people questions in rooms with no windows.

His chapters are the reason half of grimdark exists. He's in constant pain, he's vicious, he's horribly funny, and every so often he does something almost decent and hates himself for it. If what you want is a state-employed monster who is also the best company in the book, start here and keep going through The First Law.

The Executioness, by Tobias S. Buckell

A novella, so a good one for a single evening. Tana is a mother who takes up her sick father's job, hood and axe included, because the family needs the money. Then raiders burn her town and take her sons, and she goes after them still wearing the hood.

It's set in a shared world with Paolo Bacigalupi's The Alchemist, where every use of magic feeds a creeping, poisonous bramble. That's the kind of magic I like: it costs something, and somebody always pays. What makes Tana great is that the hood turns her into a legend she never asked to be, and the legend starts walking ahead of her.

The Thin Executioner, by Darren Shan

The YA pick, though it doesn't hold back. Jebel Rum lives in a city where the executioner is a celebrity, and his father is the executioner. Jebel is the weakling of the family, so he sets off on a long, dangerous quest to a fire god to be made invincible, dragging a slave along as the sacrifice he'll need at the end of it.

It's a road story that slowly turns its own premise inside out, and it's sharper about cruelty and power than a lot of adult fantasy. Give it to the teenager in your life, then nick it back.

The Hangman's Daughter, by Oliver Pötzsch

Not fantasy, but if you want the real texture of the job, this is where to go. It's 1659, in a small Bavarian town. Children are turning up dead with a mark on their skin, the town wants a witch, and the man expected to torture a confession out of the local midwife is the hangman, Jakob Kuisl. He doesn't believe she did it.

Kuisl is huge, clever and well read, and treated like a leper by the people he works for. That's the executioner's whole deal in one man. The author is descended from a real family of Bavarian executioners, and it shows in the detail.

The Faithful Executioner, by Joel F. Harrington

The non-fiction one, and the book I'd hand to any writer working on this kind of character. Frantz Schmidt was the executioner of Nuremberg in the late 1500s and kept a journal of his whole career. Harrington uses it to rebuild the man: the son of an executioner who inherited a job he didn't want, did it with care for decades, and spent his whole life trying to win back his family's honour.

Every cliché about the brute in the black hood falls apart about forty pages in. He was a professional. He was also, by the standards of his time, quite a thoughtful one, and that's a lot more unsettling than a brute.

Hand of the Executioner, by me

Right. My turn. Hand of the Executioner is book one of City of Chains. Viktor committed a crime too unspeakable to mention, and the Fourth Baron gave him a choice: death, or the black hood. He took the hood, so now he's the executioner of Adelstrad, a fortress city where the living scheme and the dead are put to work, and the most hated man in it.

The guilds want him gutted. The nobles want his wages cut. A smuggler is bringing a stupid amount of blue pixiedust through the gates, and the Watch Captain dangles a pardon in front of him if he'll help sort it out. Viktor would quite like that pardon. He would also quite like a pay rise, and he's been asking for one for five books.

It's grimdark, but it's funny, crude and a bit unhinged, and a lot of it is about how a city actually runs: the law, the guilds, the money, and the correct way to do a beheading. If Glokta's chapters were your favourite bit of The First Law, you're my kind of reader. It's in Kindle Unlimited, and if you want the full picture of my books first, the where to start page lays it all out.

Why the executioner works

Every one of these books gets the same thing right. The executioner is the only person in the story who can't pretend. Kings sign the order and go to dinner. The crowd watches and goes home. He's the one who has to do it, look at it, and clean up afterwards, so he ends up seeing the whole machine with nothing in the way.

Put that man at the centre of a fantasy and you get politics, horror and a fair bit of black comedy, whether you want it or not.

If I've missed your favourite, tell me. I'm always after more of these, mostly for research, and partly because I'm starting to suspect there's a support group to be organised. The rest of my books are on the books page.

 
 
 

Comments


Copyright Sebastian Priest 2022. All rights reserved. Designed by Studio Rainn. 

bottom of page